From idea to market – which patent analysis do you need?

Could your idea be patented, and how might other parties’ patents affect your product launch? What can competitors’ patenting activity tell you about technological developments? Choosing the right patent study helps you find the information you need to support your decisions.

Patent studies prepared by a patent attorney offer support to a wide range of decisions: protecting a new invention, bringing a product to market, or understanding your technology landscape and competitors’ activities. 

Different studies answer different questions, and their usefulness also depends on the stage of product development or business planning. It is therefore worth discussing the objectives, scope and timing of a study with a patent attorney.

From a new idea towards a patent

When a new invention begins to take shape, some of its details may still need refining. A novelty search investigates whether someone has already disclosed the same solution. The results help assess whether the invention is ready for patenting or whether it should be developed further in a particular direction to distinguish it from the prior art. 

Novelty alone, however, is not enough to obtain a patent: the patent office also assesses inventive step and industrial applicability. Inventive step means that the solution is not an obvious combination of existing knowledge, but differs substantially from what was previously known. A patentability assessment can evaluate these requirements before a final decision is made on whether to seek patent protection for the invention. 

Both novelty searches and patentability assessments consider all types of publicly available material. Patent publications relating to rights that are no longer in force, as well as applications that never resulted in a granted patent, may therefore be relevant. The findings also support the drafting of the patent application: they help the patent attorney compare the invention with the prior art and highlight the features that distinguish it. 

How do other parties’ patents affect us?

In addition to protecting new inventions, existing patents should also be considered when bringing finished products to market, as other parties’ patents may restrict their manufacture or sale. A freedom-to-operate (FTO) analysis assesses whether your product or process can be manufactured, used or sold without infringing other companies’ patents.  

Unlike a novelty search, an FTO analysis focuses on patents that are in force and potentially also on pending patent applications. Since patent protection is territorial, the situation must be assessed separately in each country relevant to your operations. An analysis covering several countries can therefore be time-consuming and involve substantial costs. 

It is important to distinguish between novelty and freedom to operate. Even if a novelty search does not identify a previously published solution that is exactly the same, this does not mean that the product can be freely manufactured or sold. A competitor’s broader patent may also cover your solution, or a competitor’s patent may relate to only some of the product’s features. The questions “Can I obtain a patent?” and “Can I use the technology?” therefore each require a separate assessment. 

Competitors’ patents – monitoring and taking action

To stay informed about specific competitors’ activities, their patenting can be monitored systematically. Competitor monitoring tracks the patenting activity of one or more competitors. For example, monitoring can be limited to a particular technology area within a large company’s operations. This helps you keep up with competitors’ activities and identify patents that may affect your freedom to operate at an early stage. The findings also support business planning and help you focus your own activities on particular fields. 

If a competitor has a patent or patent application that threatens your freedom to operate, you may consider challenging it, for example by filing third-party observations, an opposition or an invalidity action. A patent invalidity analysis assesses the validity of a patent and investigates the grounds on which it could be challenged. 

The findings of an invalidity analysis help you decide whether to challenge the patent or whether, for example, negotiations with the other company might be a viable alternative. The analysis also provides a basis for the patent attorney to plan any challenge in greater detail.

Where is technology heading?

Beyond individual competitors, you may be interested in the technology landscape as a whole: what kinds of solutions are being developed, and where is the field heading? Technology monitoring tracks current patenting activity in a particular technology area, regardless of who is filing the applications. Like competitor monitoring, it helps identify patents that could threaten your freedom to operate and supports business planning. 

A patent landscape analysis, in turn, provides an overview of a selected technology area. It shows how the technology has developed in recent years and what patenting activity suggests about its future direction. Visual analyses illustrate developments across different periods, companies, geographical regions and technology classes. 

A patent landscape analysis is a strategic tool that supports IP strategy and product development planning, market analysis, investment decisions and an understanding of competitors’ positions. It often also serves as a starting point for competitor monitoring and ongoing technology monitoring.

Choosing the right study to support your decisions

Patent studies answer different questions. Choosing the right study starts with identifying the decision you need the information to support. A novelty search helps establish what has already been published on the subject, whereas a freedom-to-operate analysis assesses relevant patents that are in force and rights that may take effect in the future. Competitor monitoring provides information on competitors’ current activities, while a patent landscape analysis illustrates technological developments and their possible future directions. 

It is wise to investigate early on whether other parties’ patents could affect your plans. Together with a patent professional, you can assess which type of study best supports your next decisions and when each study would be most useful.  

Situation Question Recommended study 
You have developed a new invention Is the invention new? Novelty search 
You are deciding whether to seek patent protection Could the invention be patented? Patentability assessment 
You are preparing to launch a product Can we use or sell the product without risking infringement? Freedom-to-operate (FTO) analysis 
You are monitoring competitors What are our specific competitors doing right now? Competitor monitoring 
You are assessing a competitor’s patent Can the competitor’s patent be challenged? Invalidity analysis 
You are tracking technology trends How are specific technologies developing right now? Technology monitoring 
You are developing an IP strategy What trends are emerging in the technology landscape? Patent landscape analysis 

Latest blog articles

From idea to market – which patent analysis do you need?

A drafting checklist for chemical and pharmaceutical applications

Egg carton illustrates how to package inventions for the Unified Patent Court

When a Descriptive Trademark Comes at a Cost: The SÄHKÖMESSUT Case

Sufficiency at the EPO: two recent cases 

Writer